Please take a moment to read the story linked above. I will give a brief summary here.
A couple from Eden, NC was arrested in connection to the death of their 17 month old daughter named Toni. The following is excerpted from the report:
The warrant for Antonio Gwynn said that he restrained the toddler in a car seat for more than 15 hours without food or water.
After 12 hours, he pushed a blanket into the mouth of Toni Gwynn “in order to stop child from crying and thus restricted the airway causing the child’s death,” according to the arrest warrant.
This story makes me sick to my stomach! As a parent of three myself with one of them being an infant, I cannot fathom how any person could do this to a defenseless child! Evil is the only word that fits this crime, but even that word is not harsh enough.
I do not want to comment on the parents’ guilt or innocence. Remember, they are presumed to be innocent until proven guilty. Some facts gathered from the report and arrest warrant are:
1. A 17 month old child died.
2. The child (Toni) was strapped in a car seat for an estimated period of 15 hours.
3. The child is believed to have died of asphyxiation from a blanket being pushed into her mouth.
These facts are just based upon this one report. I have not seen the evidence myself nor talked to witnesses. So, I do not claim to know these facts as proof beyond a reasonable doubt about the incident. But let’s go with them for the sake of this article since a magistrate saw enough probable cause to issue arrest warrants.
Now, I want to give you two hypothetical scenarios. Each one will have questions that I want you to answer honestly. Remember your answers and do not read ahead (I know! Telling some of you not to read ahead has caused you to skip to the end already!). If you cannot answer the same way to the last set of questions as the first, you are being intellectually dishonest.
1. Suppose there was a third person involved in this incident. This person knew the child was being held hostage in a car seat. This person was also in the room with the child. He or she was watching as the child suffered. Not only that, but this person had the ability and power to stop the this incident. Would you think this person should be held morally accountable? Would you consider him or her to be a good person? Would you believe this person loved the child?
2. Suppose a cop is walking his beat. He passes a building and turns down a dark alley. He begins to hear the sound of a woman in distress. She is yelling for help. The cop shines his flashlight around and discovers that a man is raping this woman in the alley. The cop runs up close to the incident and stops. He tells the woman, “I am here for you. I will protect you.” Then he just stands there. He knows what is happening. He is present at the incident. He has the power to stop it. The rapist finishes his evil deed and flees the scene. The cop does not give chase. The cop tells the woman, ” See, I told you I would protect you. I love you.” She screams, “You didn’t do anything! Why didn’t you stop him?” The cop replies, “I could not violate his free will.” Would you say this was a good cop? How would you feel if somebody told you, “You should be thankful to the cop that you made it out alive”? Did this cop protect her?
I think I know how any reasonable and moral person would answer these questions. Yet, the Christian God falls into the category of the cop and supposed third person of our scenarios. According to Christian theology, God is omniscient (all knowing), omnipotent (all powerful), omnipresent (all places), and omnibenevolent (all good). Then it follows that God was at the house in Eden, NC as this infant was being tortured and suffocated. He knew that it was happening. He had the power to stop it. And since He is all-good, He should want to stop it. Yet, He did nothing. Christians, should God be held morally accountable? Do you still consider Him good? Did He love her? There is no difference in God being there and this hypothetical third person. So, if you answer differently, you have to explain why. I don’t want you to try to answer these questions to me, but answer truthfully to yourself.
Consider the second scenario. Even though it is an imaginary scenario, God could be equated with this cop for every rape that has occurred. Why would a rape victim be told to pray to the person that was present when the incident transpired, but did not do anything?
I know a lot of you are probably upset or saddened to read these challenging questions from me. These are issues I have struggled with for years. I used to make excuses and try to make it all work because I wanted to believe. Finally, I realized that I was not being honest, and my arguments fell short. I do not imagine that I have changed anyone’s mind with this article, but I hope it will challenge you.
P.S. I know many of you are probably wanting to bring up the argument of free will. That God gave humans the ability to choose and God cannot or will not violate man’s free will. I think this argument fails on many fronts. I will deal with this argument in my next blog post.